All Lives Matter?

“All lives matter.”  That sounds good doesn’t it.  It sounds good to me.  It sounds just, it sounds right, it sounds inclusive and appropriate.  It sounds like a thoughtful response to the chant “Black Lives Matter” that seems exclusive.

The problem is it misses the point.  It misses the point that Black Lives Matter founders and followers are trying to make.  It misses the point that white lives have always mattered in our culture.  From the beginning of our nation’s history there has never been any question about white lives mattering.  It isn’t an issue that needs addressing.  White lives have mattered a great deal for a very long time.  But the intrinsic value and created worth of Black lives and other lives of people of color, have not had that same history.  Therefore, the need to lift up their value is critical even as we lift up the ongoing mistreatment of Black lives even today in 2016.  Be it the mass incarceration of Black people, to a large extent based upon ongoing racist policies continued from the 1970’s or the profiling and violent treatment of black citizens that has always taken place, but is now coming to the attention of the public because it’s being captured on video.  Be it the systemic racism that continues to keep people of color economically disenfranchised, or the stereotyping that is done on a daily basis.  The situation for Black lives is clearly and profoundly disproportionately negative to white lives.

I heard recently what was for me a helpful metaphor for the point Black Lives Matter is seeking to make.  The image was of a meal with several white people gathered around the table with plates filled with food and a person of color also at the table with nothing on their plate.  The person of color says, “I’m hungry,” the others around the table with plates filled with food say, “well we’re hungry too.”

All lives will matter when black lives matter! 

I know this is hard to take as a white person.  I know we want to proclaim our innocence and deny our culpability.  We want to say we are not racist and we want everyone to be equal.  But for any of that to be true we must be willing to name our white privilege.  We must be willing to name the fact that too often police treat white people and black people differently.  Not every officer, not every department.  But there is a long history of profiling and too often violence and death that we cannot deny.  Almost every person of color could share a story about their experience of it if we were willing to listen.  And we must listen to those stories.  We must understand that our guilt, or our empathy isn’t enough.  Because at the end of the day, what it all comes down to is this; we (white people), can take or leave the struggle.  We can go home, as white people and choose whether to engage the conversation or the fight or not to.  We can go home to our plate of food and leave the issue behind.  Even the most justice minded among us always have that choice.  But people of color don’t.  They’re always, always, 24/7 the black skinned person being pulled over for a broken tail light.

I hate that 5 police officers were killed in Dallas this week.  I am appalled by it.  I don’t condone any violence towards any end.  It’s always wrong and it should always be condemned.  But while we mourn with the families of these officers we must keep in perspective that a call for justice, taken by a mentally unbalanced individual as somehow a call to commit horrific acts, does not negate the importance or appropriateness of the original call.

Friends, Black Lives Matter.  And all lives will matter when that statement is lived out in every area and in every aspect of our culture.


6 thoughts on “All Lives Matter?

  1. Thank you Bill for writing this and sharing this word. We all need to be part of the solution to what is going on and it starts with conversations and realizations especially for those of us in priveledged communities of the reality of racism in our nation. As Dr. King said, “injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere”. May we all work on changing this reality. As one of favorite hymns says “Let peace begin with me” Thank you for speaking this truth.

  2. Thank you Bill, for your kind and thoughtful comments. A person of color is reminded, every morning when they look in the mirror, of the challenges they face just because of their skin color.
    We are all, obligated to follow the Law. That is a given. But if we really believe that all lives matter, regardless of race or ethnicity, we need to walk in each others shoes, and learn about each others pain. Set aside the stereotypes, and learn truths about each other.

  3. My son & I started discussing this issue several months ago. If you are white & poor you have a better chance to dig out from under that “stigma” than if you are black & poor. I don’t consider myself racist but I also made the mistake of not thinking about white privilege. I grew up poor but I am white & live in area that gave me a better chance to change that. What would have happened if I would have been black & living in the inner city?

  4. well framed . . . thanks

    Hard lesson for one at the table – need to include those on the margins. Think I read that in the Gospels

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *